This is kind of meaningless: a lot of pages use javascript, but use it in such a way that they degrade gracefully if the scripting is not enabled.
Also, the penetration numbers you cite are both inaccurate and misleading. They don't take into account things like noscript users, smartphones (which often have very buggy javascript implementations) and they don't account for google, which doesn't process your javascript when indexing the site. Also, 95% javascript penetration sounds higher than it is. Taken the other way, at least one person in 20 who visits you site won't have javascript.
Finally, you should consider your audience. You might be developing for a corporate intranet site where you can enforce browser settings and guarantee that number is 100%, or you might be doing a site for the U.S. goverment and be legally required to support screen readers.
Here are some similar SO questions: