views:

1117

answers:

4

Hello. Is it possible to return an object from a static method in C++ like there is in Java? I am doing this:

class MyMath {
    public:
       static MyObject calcSomething(void);
    private:
};

And I want to do this:

int main() { 
    MyObject o = MyMath.calcSomething(); // error happens here
}

There are only static methods in the MyMath class, so there's no point in instantiating it. But I get this compile error:

MyMath.cpp:69: error: expected primary-expression before '.' token

What am I doing wrong? Do I have to instantiate MyMath? I would rather not, if it is possible.

+8  A: 

What am I doing wrong?

You are simply using incorrect syntax... the :: operator (scope resolution operator) is how you would access classes or members in different namespaces:

int main() { 
    MyObject o = MyMath::calcSomething(); // correct syntax
}

Do I have to instantiate MyMath?

No.

John Rasch
+11  A: 

Use :: instead of .

MyObject o = MyMath::calcSomething();

When you are calling the method without the object of the class you should use :: notation. You may also call static method via class objects or pointers to them, in this case you should use usual . or -> notation:

MyObject obj;
MyObject* p = new MyObject();

MyObject::calcSomething();
obj.calcSomething();
p->calcSomething();
Paul
+1 for noting that you can still call a static function via object-> notation.
Jim Buck
A: 

For this case, you want MyMath::calcSomething(). The '.' syntax is for calling functions in objects. The :: syntax is for calling functions in a class or a namespace.

Michael Kohne
A: 

Call MyMath::calcSomething()

Marten