tags:

views:

814

answers:

2

The following code

#include <iostream>    
using namespace std;

int main()
{
    const char* const foo = "f";
    const char bar[] = "b";
    cout << "sizeof(string literal) = " << sizeof( "f" ) << endl;
    cout << "sizeof(const char* const) = " << sizeof( foo ) << endl;
    cout << "sizeof(const char[]) = " << sizeof( bar ) << endl;
}

outputs

sizeof(string literal) = 2
sizeof(const char* const) = 4
sizeof(const char[]) = 2

on a 32bit OS, compiled with GCC.

  1. Why does sizeof calculate the length of (the space needed for) the string literal ?
  2. Does the string literal have a different type (from char* or char[]) when given to sizeof ?
+6  A: 

sizeof returns the size in bytes of its operand. That should answer question number 1. ;) Also, a string literal is of type "array to n const char" when passed to sizeof.

Your test cases, one by one:

  • "f" is a string literal consisting of two characters, the character f and the terminating NULL.
  • foo is a pointer (edit: regardless of qualifiers), and pointers seem to be 4 bytes long on your system..
  • For bar the case is the same as "f".

Hope that helps.

Michael Foukarakis
Why is a `char[]` the same as a striong literal though? I'm not a C/C++ expert, but I thought that `char[]` and `char*` were interchangable?
Matthew Scharley
+1 on the general answer (and for speed :) A couple of precisions: foo IS a pointer (essentially qualifier does not apply) and in C++ the type is always "array of n const char" (constant-ness is not optional)
David Rodríguez - dribeas
@dribeas: right you are, const always applies. @Matthew: char* and char[] are only the same under certain circumstances, the sizeof operator is not one of them.
Michael Foukarakis
@Matthew: Nope, arrays and pointers are *not* interchangeable. An array can be passed whenever a pointer is expected, as it *decays* to a pointer. But as long as the type is an array, it is *not* the same as a pointer.
jalf
+16  A: 
  1. sizeof("f") must return 2, one for the 'f' and one for the terminating '\0'.
  2. sizeof(foo) returns 4 on a 32-bit machine and 8 on a 64-bit machine because foo is a pointer
  3. sizeof(bar) returns 2 because bar is an array of two characters, the 'b' and the terminating '\0'.

The string literal has the type 'array of size N of char' where N includes the terminal null.

Remember, arrays do not decay to pointers when passed to sizeof.

Jonathan Leffler
+1, but the type is actually 'array of N const characters' (const is not optional)
David Rodríguez - dribeas
@dribeas: yes; I was ignoring the qualifiers, but you are pedantically correct.
Jonathan Leffler