views:

384

answers:

3

if you tell an objective c object to removeObservers: for a key path and that key path has not been registered, it cracks the sads. like -

'Cannot remove an observer for the key path "theKeyPath" from because it is not registered as an observer.'

is there a way to determine if an object has a registered observer, so i can do this

if (object has observer){
  remove observer
}
else{
  go on my merry way
}
+3  A: 

The real question is why you don't know whether you're observing it or not.

If you're doing this in the class of the object being observed, stop. Whatever's observing it expects to keep observing it. If you cut off the observer's notifications without its knowledge, expect things to break; more specifically, expect the observer's state to go stale as it doesn't receive updates from the formerly-observed object.

If you're doing this in the observing object's class, simply remember which objects you're observing (or, if you only ever observe one object, whether you're observing it). This is assuming that the observation is dynamic and between two otherwise-unrelated objects; if the observer owns the observed, just add the observer after you create or retain the observed, and remove the observer before you release the observed.

Adding and removing an object as an observer should usually happen in the observer's class, and never in the observed object's.

Peter Hosey
A: 

The only way to do this is to set a flag when you add an observer.

Leibowitzn
+2  A: 

The whole point of the observer pattern is to allow an observed class to be "sealed" -- to not know or care whether it is being observed. You are explicitly trying to break this pattern.

Why?

The problem you are having is that you are assuming you are being observed when you aren't. This object did not start the observation. If you want your class to have control of this process, then you should consider using the notification center. That way your class has full control on when data can be observed. Hence, it doesn't care who is watching.

Andrew

adonoho