How many different ways are there to concatenate two files line by line using Perl?

Question

Suppose file1 looks like this:

bye bye
hello
thank you

And file2 looks like this:

chao
hola
gracias

The desired output is this:

bye bye chao
hello hola
thank you gracias

I myself have already come up with five different approaches to solve this problem. But I think there must be more ways, probably more concise and more elegant ways, and I hope I can learn more cool stuff :)

The following is what I have tried so far, based on what I've learnt from the many solutions of my previous problems. Also, I'm trying to sort of digest or internalize the knowledge I've acquired from the Llama book.

Code 1:

#!perl
use autodie;
use warnings;
use strict;

open my $file1,'<','c:/file1.txt';
open my $file2,'<','c:/file2.txt';

while(defined(my $line1 = <$file1>)
        and defined(my $line2 = <$file2>)){
    die "Files are different sizes!\n" unless eof(file1) == eof(file2);
    $line1 .= $line2;
    $line1 =~ s/\n/ /;
    print "$line1 \n";
}

Code 2:

#!perl
use autodie;
use warnings;
use strict;

open my $file1,'<','c:/file1.txt';
my @file1 = <$file1>;

open my $file2,'<','c:/file2.txt';
my @file2 =<$file2>;

for (my $n=0; $n<=$#file1; $n++) {
    $file1[$n] .=$file2[$n];
    $file1[$n]=~s/\n/ /;
    print $file1[$n];
}

Code 3:

#!perl
use autodie;
use warnings;
use strict;

open my $file1,'<','c:/file1.txt';
open my $file2,'<','c:/file2.txt';

my %hash;

while(defined(my $line1 = <$file1>)
      and defined(my $line2 = <$file2>)) {
  chomp $line1;
  chomp $line2;
  my ($key, $val) = ($line1,$line2);
  $hash{$key} = $val;
}
print map { "$_ $hash{$_}\n" } sort keys %hash;

Code 4:

#!perl
use autodie;
use warnings;
use strict;

open my $file1,'<','c:/file1.txt';
open my $file2,'<','c:/file2.txt';

while(defined(my $line1 = <$file1>)
      and defined(my $line2 = <$file2>)) {
  $line1 =~ s/(.+)/$1 $line2/;
  print $line1;
}

Code 5:

#!perl
use autodie;
use warnings;
use strict;

open my $file1,'<','c:/file1.txt';
my @file1 =<$file1>;

open my $file2,'<','c:/file2.txt';
my @file2 =<$file2>;

while ((@file1) && (@file2)){ 
    my $m = shift (@file1);
    chomp($m);

    my $n = shift (@file2);
    chomp($n);

    $m .=" ".$n;
    print "$m \n";
}

I have tried something like this:

foreach $file1 (@file2) && foreach $file2 (@file2) {...}

But Perl gave me a syntactic error warning. I was frustrated. But can we run two foreach loops simultaneously?

Thanks, as always, for any comments, suggestions and of course the generous code sharing :)

Answer 1

An easy one with minimal error checking:

#!/usr/bin/perl -w

use strict;

open FILE1, '<file1.txt';
open FILE2, '<file2.txt';

while (defined(my $one = <FILE1>) or defined(my $twotemp = <FILE2>)){
    my $two = $twotemp ? $twotemp : <FILE2>;
    chomp $one if ($one);
    chomp $two if ($two);
    print ''.($one ? "$one " : '').($two ? $two : '')."\n";
}

And no, you can't run two loops simultaneous within the same thread, you'd have to fork, but that would not be guaranteed to run synchronously.

Answer 2

An easier alternative to your Code 5 which allows for an arbitrary number of lines and does not care if files have different numbers of lines (hat tip @FM):

#!/usr/bin/perl

use strict; use warnings;

use File::Slurp;
use List::AllUtils qw( each_arrayref );

my @lines = map [ read_file $_ ], @ARGV;

my $it = each_arrayref @lines;

while ( my @lines = grep { defined and chomp and length } $it->() ) {
    print join(' ', @lines), "\n";
}

And, without using any external modules:

#!perl
use autodie; use warnings; use strict;

my ($file1, $file2) = @ARGV;

open my $file1_h,'<', $file1;
my @file1 = grep { chomp; length } <$file1_h>;

open my $file2_h,'<', $file2;
my @file2 =  grep { chomp; length } <$file2_h>;

my $n_lines = @file1 > @file2 ? @file1 : @file2;

for my $i (0 .. $n_lines - 1) {
    my ($line1, $line2) = map {
        defined $_ ? $_ : ''
    } $file1[$i], $file2[$i];
    print $line1, ' ', $line2, "\n";
}

If you want to concatenate only the lines that appear in both files:

#!perl
use autodie; use warnings; use strict;

my ($file1, $file2) = @ARGV;

open my $file1_h,'<', $file1;
my @file1 = grep { chomp; length } <$file1_h>;

open my $file2_h,'<', $file2;
my @file2 =  grep { chomp; length } <$file2_h>;

my $n_lines = @file1 < @file2 ? @file1 : @file2;

for my $i (0 .. $n_lines - 1) {
    print $file1[$i], ' ', $file2[$i], "\n";
}

Answer 3

use strict;
use warnings;
use autodie;

my @handles = map { open my $h, '<', $_; $h } @ARGV;

while (@handles){
    @handles = grep { ! eof $_ } @handles;
    my @lines = map { my $v = <$_>; chomp $v; $v } @handles;
    print join(' ', @lines), "\n";
}

close $_ for @handles;

Answer 4

The most elegant way doesn't involve perl at all:

paste -d' ' file1 file2