views:

973

answers:

3

Hi,

I'd like to have a way in which 'mvn install' puts files in a repository folder under my source (checkout) root, while using 3rd party dependencies from ~/.m2/repository.

So after 'mvn install', the layout is:

/work/project/
    repository
      com/example/foo-1.0.jar
      com/example/bar-1.0.jar
    foo
      src/main/java
    bar
      src/main/java

~/.m2/repository
    log4j/log4j/1.2/log4j-1.2.jar

(In particular, /work/project/repository does not contain log4j)

In essense, I'm looking for a way of creating a composite repository that references other repositories

EDIT: My intention is to be able to have multiple checkouts of the same source and work on each without overwriting each other in the local repository with 'install'. multiple checkouts can be because of working on different branches in cvs/svn but in my case it is due to cloning of the master branch in git (in git, each clone is like a branch). i don't like the alternatives which are to use a special version/classifier per checkout or to reinstall (rebuild) everything each time i switch.

A: 

This is not possible with the command line client but you can create more complex repository layouts with a Maven repository server like Nexus.

The reason why it's not possible is that Maven allows to nest projects and most of them will reference each other, so installing each artifact in a different repository would lead to lots of searches on your local hard disk (or to failed builds when you start a build in a sub-project).

Aaron Digulla
You're describing how to create a remote composite repository. I'm looking for something similar, but for a local repository. (search in different folders, install into one)
IttayD
Install Nexus on your local computer to get this behavior. But as I said: It's not possible to achieve with Maven alone.
Aaron Digulla
even with nexus, i will still need a local repository where maven will download all 3rd party artifacts.
IttayD
There is no way to keep the local repository clean.
Aaron Digulla
btw, about the reason, i don't see why this is a problem. i simply want to be able to specify 2 local repositories that are searched where one is designated as the 'install-to' repository and the other as the 'download-to' repository. if i have several projects where each has a different 'install-to' repository, then this is a configuration problem i need to fix.
IttayD
@IttayD: It's not possible because the settings file allows only a single path. If you need more, you must download the source for Maven, find the plugin(s) which read this property and patch them to accept a list instead.
Aaron Digulla
+1  A: 

Maven can search multiple repositories (local, remote, "fake" remote) to resolve dependencies but there is only ONE local repository where artifacts get installed during install. It would be a real nightmare to install artifacts into specific locations and to maintain this list without breaking anything, that would just not work, you don't want to do this.

But, TBH, I don't get the point. So, why the hell do you want to do this? There might be alternative and much simpler solutions, like installing your artifacts in the local repository and then copying them under your project root. Why wouldn't this work? I'd really like to know the final intention though.

UPDATE: Having read the update of the initial question, the only solution I can think of (given that you don't want to use different versions/tags) would be to use two local repositories and to switch between them (very error prone though).

To do so, either use different user accounts (as the local repository is user specific by default).

Or update your ~/.m2/settings.xml each time you want to switch:

<settings xmlns="http://maven.apache.org/SETTINGS/1.0.0"
  xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
  xsi:schemaLocation="http://maven.apache.org/SETTINGS/1.0.0
                      http://maven.apache.org/xsd/settings-1.0.0.xsd"&gt;
  <localRepository>${user.home}/.m2/repository</localRepository>
  <!--localRepository>${user.home}/.m2/repository2</localRepository-->
  ...
</settings>

Or have another settings.xml and point on it using the --settings option:

mvn install --settings /path/to/alternate/settings.xml

Or specify the alternate location on the command line using the -Dmaven.repo.local option:

mvn -Dmaven.repo.local=/path/to/repo

These solutions are all error prone as I said and none of them is very satisfying. Even if you might have very good reasons to work on several branches in parallel, your use case (not rebuilding everything) is not very common. Here, using distinct user accounts migh be the less worse solution IMO.

Pascal Thivent
i didn't ask how i can install to multiple repositories and my example shows the files are installed in one repository (/work/project/repository). how do i tell maven to search for multiple repositories on local disk? i know of the "fake" remote repository technique, but this causes maven to copy the files from the fake remote to the local repository.
IttayD
Well, this may not be what you asked for but this is what you are trying to do and, in your example, there are indeed 2 local repositories: `/work/project/repository` and `~/.m2/repository`. But this is not possible, there is only ONE local repository (wherever it's located). Please clarify what you are trying to achieve and your needs. As I said, I don't get the whole thing.
Pascal Thivent
added my intention
IttayD
thanks for the effort. in both cases, the local repository will also be populated with all 3rd party artifacts, wasting disk space. marking as a solution since it probably doesn't get any better
IttayD
A: 

I think that what you're looking for is the dependency:copy-dependencies goal

See: http://maven.apache.org/plugins/maven-dependency-plugin/copy-dependencies-mojo.html

This is often performed as a prelude to building an installable package, or if you want to invoke a third-party tool that will build a classpath from all jars in a specified directory.

Kevin Wright