Cocoa window position anomaly

Question

Hello everyone,

I have a weird problem with positioning a window on screen. I want to center the window on the screen, but i don't know how to do that. Here's what i've got. The window is created from nib by the main controller:

IdentFormController *ftf = [[IdentFormController alloc] initWithWindowNibName:@"IdentForm"];
[[ftf window] makeKeyAndOrderFront:self];

Now the IdentFormController has awakeFromNib() method in which it tries to position the window. For the sake of simplicity i've just tried to do setFrameOrigin(NSMakePoint(0, 0)). What happens is as follows:

The first time i create this window, everything works as expected. But if i create it again after releasing the previous, it starts appearing at random positions. Why does it do that?

Answer 1

This isn't a duplicate, but you may want to have a look at the answers to this question: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1855034/centering-windows-on-screen

Answer 2

First of all, it sounds like you need to check "dealloc on close" or "release on close" in the NSWindow's property inspector. Then the window will clean up after itself and you can remove the (risky) call to [self release] in your own code.

awakeFromNib is called after all objects from the nib have been unarchived and outlets have been connected, but that may be too early to be setting the window coordinates. I believe Cocoa does some work to automatically position subsequent windows below and to the right of existing windows, so that new windows don't completely obscure old ones. It is likely doing this AFTER you set the position in awakeFromNib, stomping on your changes.

The best place to set your window position is probably in one of the NSWindow delegate methods (windowWillBecomeVisible: perhaps), or possibly right before you call makeKeyAndOrderFront:.

Answer 3

Check out if you can set the centre of your window with the centre of your screen. And set the window position on it. It might work out.

Answer 4

So as I understand it you want to center the window on the screen?

Well assuming NSWindow *window is your window object then there are two methods...

[window center];

This is the best way to do it but it will ofset to take into account visual weight and the Dock's presence.

If you want dead center then this would work...

// Calculate the actual center
NSPoint x = (window.screen.frame.size.width - window.size.width) / 2;
NSPoint y = (window.screen.frame.size.height - window.size.height) / 2;

// Create a rect to send to the window
NSRect newFrame = NSMakeRect(x, y, window.size.width, window.size.height);

// Send message to the window to resize/relocate
[window setFrame:newFrame display:YES animate:NO];

This code is untested but it gives you a fair idea of what you need to do to get this thing working the way you want, personally I would advise you stick with Apple's code because it has been tested and is what the user would expect to see, also from a design perspective as a designer my self I don't always rely on the actual center to be where the optical center is.

Answer 5

You're probably running afoul of automatic window positioning. Have you tried calling

[myWindowController setShouldCascadeWindows: NO];

?

Answer 6

Would be nice if you would give credit to those who gave you your answer otherwise none who find this question on search will know what the solution was.