I'm working on a couple of web services that use JAXB bindings for the messages (in JAX-WS or spring-ws). When using these bindings there's always some code that is automatically generated from the WSDL to bind the message objects. I'm struggling to figure out the best way I can make this work so that it's easy to work with, hard to break and integrates nicely with IDEs (mostly using eclipse).
I think there are a couple of ways to go about this. The three main options I see right now are:
- Generate code, keep the source artifacts and check them into the repository. Pros: integrates easily with IDEs (source highlighting etc), works within the build system. Cons: generated code changes each time you regenerate it, possibly creating noisy commits. It's also redundant since the WSDL file is already checked in, usually.
- Generate code as part of the build process. Don't keep source artifacts or only keep them in output directories. Pros: fixes all the cons from the previous one. Cons: harder to integrate with IDE, though maybe this build step can be run automatically? I currently use this on one of my projects but the first time I checkout the project it appears broken, which is a minor nuisance.
- Keep generated bindings in separate libraries (jars) included with maven or manually updated jars, depending on your build process. I got the idea from a thread on java.net. This seems more stable and uses explicit versioning but seems a bit heavyweight.
Which one of these options would you implement and how? We're currently using maven and eclipse, so any ideas in that regard would be great. I think this problem generalises to most other build systems and IDE combinations though, even other languages perhaps.