views:

156

answers:

2

Hi, I'm having a problem with scala generics. While the first function I defined here seems to be perfectly ok, the compiler complains about the second definition with:

error: Parameter type in structural refinement may not refer to an abstract type defined outside that refinement
    def >>[B](a: C[B])(implicit m: Monad[C]): C[B] = {
        ^

What am I doing wrong here?

   trait Lifter[C[_]] {
      implicit def liftToMonad[A](c: C[A]) = new {
        def >>=[B](f: A => C[B])(implicit m: Monad[C]): C[B] = { 
          m >>= (c, f)
        }   
        def >>[B](a: C[B])(implicit m: Monad[C]): C[B] = { 
          m >> a
        }   
      }
    }

IMPORTANT: This is NOT a question about Monads, it's a question about scala polymorphism in general.

EDIT: Here is my Monad definition

trait Monad[C[_]] {
  def >>=[A, B](a: C[A], f: A => C[B]): C[B]
  def >>=[B](a: C[B]): C[B]
  def apply[A](a: A): C[A]
}

BTW: I'm using scala 2.8RC1

Regards, raichoo

+7  A: 

Filling in the blanks in your example, I made this compile:

trait Monad[C[_]] {
  def >>=[A, B](f: A => C[B]): C[B]
  def >>[B](a: C[B]): C[B]
}

trait Lifter[C[_]] {
  class D {
    def >>=[A, B](f: A => C[B])(implicit m: Monad[C]): C[B] = {
      m >>= f
    }
    def >>[B](a: C[B])(implicit m: Monad[C]): C[B] = {
      m >> a
    }
  }

  implicit def liftToMonad[A](c: C[A]) = new D
}
Randall Schulz
A: 

Thanks, that really helped. Your answer pointed me into the right direction. I wrote the thing to this:

trait Lifter[C[_]] {
  class Wrapper[A](c: C[A])  {
    def >>=[B](f: A => C[B])(implicit m: Monad[C]): C[B] = { 
      m >>= (c, f)
    }   
    def >>[B](b: C[B])(implicit m: Monad[C]): C[B] = { 
      m >> (c, b)
    }   
  }

  implicit def liftToMonad[A](c: C[A]): Wrapper[A] = new Wrapper(c)
}

Thanks a lot.

Regards, raichoo

raichoo