tags:

views:

143

answers:

2

This is a realistic question in my study design needed to be solved. Please help.

In a 3-cm2 big circle (area=3-cm2, so calculated radius of this big circle=9.77 mm), I need to put 12 small holes (all of same dimension). They should be evenly distributed with 4mm spacing from each other, and should be as close to the edge of the big circle as possible. How to position these small holes and how to calculate radius of the small holes?

Thanks

A: 

start with placing them at the edge and proceed along a spiral towards the center. their radii depend on whether their proximity to the edge is more important than their size.

akonsu
Size is not important as long as they are distributed evenly in the big circle and have 4-mm spacing. It is better to place some holes near the big circle edge, but firstly, they should be evenly distributed.I had tried to put 8 holes at the edges (0, 45, 90, 135, 180, 225, 270, 315, 360 degrees). Add 4 near the center of the big circle, the center of each small circle form an equilateral triangle together with the centers of the other 2 small circles located at the big circle edge. But still I can not calculate the radius. Please help. Thanks
Naomi
suppose you want to put two holes in to a circle. how would you do this to make them evenly distributed? i think your question is vague.
akonsu
one more thing: the smaller circles can either be evenly distributed inside the bigger one or they can be as close as possible to the edges. your question says that they must be both.
akonsu
How about if just one requirement: 12 smaller circles in a 3-cm2 big circle, with 4 mm spacing apart from nearby small circles?
Naomi
i think the smaller circles should be packed as bee cells. i guess there is no more optimal solution. but i cannot prove this. this is a non-trivial problem to solve.
akonsu
+10  A: 

Here you have a possible solution based on hexagonal packing:

alt text

I am not sure if this satisfies all your requirements, but I guess it will be useful for refining them in case it doesn't represent your problem.

The associated data is:

Hexagon sides -> 4.70882
Circles radii -> 0.35441
Spacing between circles -> 4

Edit/

Another possibility, based on square packing is:

alt text

The parameters for the structure are:

Squares side -> 5.65654
Circles radii -> 0.828271
Spacing between circles -> 4

Just to show you that "evenly distributed" is not a good definition: The following solution seems also to cover your requirements:

alt text

In this case, the parameters are:

Dodecagon side -> 4.84078
Circles radii -> 0.420388
Spacing between circles -> 4

By the way, the optimal packing for 12 circles is this:

alt text

Although they are not evenly distributed.

HTH!

belisarius
+1: For possible layouts and pictures.
Callum Rogers
Is it just me, or does the first diagram contain 13 circles?
Bobby Jack
@Bobby For 12 or 13 the hex pack is the same. The circle on the center is optional. Going to add that. Tnx
belisarius