Which iPhone "Active SDK" version should I use?

Question

The current (as of Dec 2008) iPhone SDK allows me to pick between 3 versions when I want to build an app: 2.0, 2.1, 2.2. -- I'll ignore 2.1 below.

My assumptions:

• 2.2 has more API functions available than 2.0,
• 2.2 has fixed bugs since 2.0,
• 2.2 is backward-compatible with 2.0 (both for building and running),
• If I build with SDK 2.0, my app will work on iPhone 2.2,
• If I build with SDK 2.2, my app won't work on iPhone 2.0.

I would think that using the earliest version that can build the app would be best, this way it will run on iPhones running older OSes.

But is there a risk that my app would be missing something if I built it with 2.0? Maybe some speed or nicer UI elements. But maybe there's not that much difference between 2.0 and 2.2 to even worry about it?

So my question is: Which SDK should I select?

1. The earlist SDK I can build with, to broaden my target market.
2. The latest SDK always, so that my app benefits from improvements -- at the cost of potentially reducing my market.

(And if the answer is obvious, why do I have a choice?!)

Answer 1

I'd pick option #1 - compile it to 2.0. This is what we do for our app. There are still a lot of people running the old 2.0 O/S and if you compile to 2.2 your app won't run on their device.

That said, if you develop your app and run into a bug and find out that it's been fixed in a later firmware version, you may not have much of an option unless there's a workaround. There are also new features added to each new version although I do not know of a comprehensive list of what those features are (at an API level).

Answer 2

You can use the iPhone OS 2.2 SDK and still compile for iPhone OS 2.0; the way you do this is the same as for Mac OS X. The SDK you use determines the most recent version of the OS you want to use API from, while the Deployment Target you use determines the least recent version of the OS you want to run on. Both of these should generally be set at the project level in Xcode.

So you can build your software against the iPhone OS 2.2 SDK and, when running on devices with 2.2 or later installed, use 2.2 features. But you can set its Deployment Target to 2.0 and not use 2.2 features when running on a device with a pre-2.2 operating system installed and your application should work fine.

Answer 3

In my testing, if you use 2.0 you can't make use of the application badge functionality - that appears in 2.1 (so you may need to at least use that level)

Tim