What's the difference between doing alloc and class_createInstance

Question

Hi,

Wondering, what is the difference between creating a class with:

Class clazz = [NSString class];
[clazz alloc];

and

class_createInstance(clazz,0);

Answer 1

One is a function, the other is a method. The function, by virtue of being a function, cannot be overloaded. The method, (since it's a method) could conceivably be implemented in a different manner.

For example, since some classes in Cocoa (collections, for example) are class clusters, it's possible that they override +alloc to implement custom behavior. You could not do that with when using a function.

Answer 2

There is a description here:

http://www.cocoabuilder.com/archive/cocoa/111527-class-createinstance-with-nsarray-nsdictionary.html

Basically, class_createInstance is for Cocoa implementors, and gives them low-level access to the process. API users should use alloc, which presumably uses class_createInstance or something like it.

Answer 3

Basically, you shouldn't be using class_createInstance() unless you know enough about what you're doing that you can answer this question yourself.

Calling class_createInstance() bypasses any special cases that have been implemented in +alloc. If you try it with NSString, you will get an NSString instance, not an instance of the private placeholder class that is the proper target for whatever -init... message you want to send it.