There are two possibilities: either your app is a one-off that just has to work right now and will never be touched, adapted, expanded or modified, or else your app is the beginning of something that you will keep working with and using over a long time.
If the former, don't break perfectly usable code. You have better things to do with your time.
If the latter, you have to bear in mind an important fact about PHP, which is this: poorly written PHP is a nightmare to maintain. Not as bad as poorly written Perl -- because what is? -- but bad enough that sooner or later you will feel a strong urge to steal a time machine, travel back to the moment you wrote the code you now find yourself maintaining, and stab yourself in the eye socket with an icepick.
So if you're going to be maintaining this code over time, take the time to do it right. That means: some kind of templating system, no PHP tags embedded inside HTML, separate files for separate functionality, and classes classes classes!
Your eye sockets will thank you.