That really depends on the scale of your project. If it’s just casual, not fully automated, I’d strongly suggest a Firefox Addon.
I’m right in the middle of similar project. It has to analyze the DOM of a page generated using Javascript. Writing a server-side browser was too difficult, so we turned to some other technologies: Adobe AIR, Firefox Addons, userscripts, etc.
Fx addon is great, if you don’t need the automation. A script can analyze the page, show you the results, ask you to correct the parts, that it is uncertain of and finally post the data to some backend. You have access to all of the DOM, so you don’t need to write a JS/CSS/HTML/whatever parser (that would be hell of a job!)
Another way is Adobe AIR. Here, you have more control over the application — you can launch it in the background, doing all the parsing and analyzing without your interaction. The downside is — you don’t have access to all DOM of the pages. The only way to go pass this is to set up a simple proxy, that fetches target URL, adds some Javascript (to create a trusted-untrusted sandbox bridge)… It’s a dirty hack, but it works.
Edit:
In Adobe AIR, there are two ways to access a foreign website’s DOM:
- Load it via Ajax, create HTMLLoader object, and feed the response into it (
loadString method IIRC)
- Create an iframe, and load the site in untrusted sandbox.
I don’t remember why, but the first method failed for me, so I had to use the other one (i think there was some security reasons involved, that I couldn’t workaround). And I had to create a sandbox, to access site’s DOM. Here’s a bit about dealing with sandbox bridges. The idea is to create a proxy, that adds a simple JS, that creates childSandboxBridge and exposes some methods to the parent (in this case: the AIR application). The script contents is something like:
window.childSandboxBridge = {
// ... some methods returning data
}
(be careful — there are limitations of what can be passed via the sandbox bridge — no complex objects for sure! use only the primitive types)
So, the proxy basically tampered with all the requests that returned HTML or XHTML. All other was just passed through unchanged. I’ve done this using Apache + PHP, but could be done with a real proxy with some plugins/custom modules for sure. This way I had the access to DOM of any site.
end of edit.
The third way I know of, the hardest way — set up an environment similar to those on browsershots. Then you’re using firefox with automation. If you have a Mac OS X on a server, you could play with ActionScript, to do the automation for you.
So, to sum up:
- PHP/server-side script — you have to implement your own browser, JS engine, CSS parser, etc, etc. Fully under control and automated instead.
- Firefox Addon — has access to DOM and all stuff. Requires user to operate it (or at least an open firefox session with some kind of autoreload). Nice interface for a user to guide the whole process.
- Adobe AIR — requires a working desktop computer, more difficult than creating a Fx addon, but more powerful.
- Automated browser — more of a desktop programming issue that webdevelopment. Can be set up on a linux terminal without graphical environment. Requires master hacking skills. :)