views:

754

answers:

4

I'm trying to extract the response header of a URL request. When I use firebug to analyze the response output of a URL request, it returns

Content-Type text/html

however when I use the python code urllib2.urlopen(URL).info() the resulting output returns

Content-Type: video/x-flv

I am new to python, and to web programming in general; any helpful insight is much appreciated. Also, if more info is needed please let me know. Thanks in advance for reading this post

A: 

This peculiar discrepancy might be explained by different headers (maybe ones of the accept kind) being sent by the two requests -- can you check that...? Or, if Javascript is running in Firefox (which I assume you're using when you're running firebug?) -- since it's definitely NOT running in the Python case -- "all bets are off", as they say;-).

Alex Martelli
hmmm, I'm not too sure how there would be two different headers and also how I would be able to distinguish between both. I'm pretty sure javascript is running in firefox... What would be necessary for me to do within python then?
looter
@looter, there's no direct way to execute Javascript in Python -- if Javascript's playing a crucial role in determining the final contents of the page, your best bet's automating real browsers instead, e.g. via SeleniumRC.
Alex Martelli
I'm not sure if Javascript is processing the requests, because when I use the network monitoring in firebug, the response header is also viewable within the HTML view. Like I mentioned in my post, I'm really new to python and web programming/scripting so some of this is going over my head, I'm not sure if I'm being descriptive enough. Thanks for your help so far.
looter
+1  A: 

Content-Type text/html

Really, like that, without the colon?

If so, that might explain it: it's an invalid header, so it gets ignored, so urllib guesses the content-type instead, by looking at the filename. If the URL happens to have ‘.flv’ at the end, it'll guess the type should be video/x-flv.

bobince
+1  A: 

Keep in mind that a web server can return different results for the same URL based on differences in the request. For example, content-type negotiation: the requestor can specify a list of content-types it will accept, and the server can return different results to try to accomodate different needs.

Also, you may be getting an error page for one of your requests, for example, because it is malformed, or you don't have cookies set that authenticate you properly, etc. Look at the response itself to see what you are getting.

Ned Batchelder
+1  A: 

Try to request as Firefox does. You can see the request headers in Firebug, so add them to your request object:

require urllib2

request = urllib2.Request('http://your.tld/...')
request.add_header('User-Agent', 'some fake agent string')
request.add_header('Referer', 'fake referrer')
...
response = urllib2.urlopen(request)
# check content type:
print response.info().getheader('Content-Type')

There's also HTTPCookieProcessor which can make it better, but I don't think you'll need it in most cases. Have a look at python's documentation:

http://docs.python.org/library/urllib2.html

qingbo