Does Anyone Still Prefer N-Tier Architecture After Having *Shipped* an MVC Application?

Question

• Other SO threads have asked people if they prefer N-Tier or MVC architecture.
• I'm not looking to continue that debate on this thread.
• I'm looking for something more specific.

My Question:

Does Anyone Still Prefer N-Tier Architecture After Having Shipped an MVC Application?

Reason for My Question:

• Before I shipped an MVC web application, I wasn't convinced that it was superior to N-Tier Architecture.
  • Specifically, if better unit testing was the only obvious benefit of MVC, then I saw no reason to switch gears and adopt a new architecture.
• But after having shipped an MVC application, I can see many benefits (which have been enumerated on other threads).

Answer 1

I can say that I have used both and prefer N-Tier. I still think its cleaner in the end. I use Layergen http://www.icemanind.com/LayerGen.aspx which will automatically build the Data layers and Business Layers for me.