views:

117

answers:

5

I have developed an app for the iPhone, and I know Apple would like any apps to support multiple orientations on the iPad, but I'm wondering if it's actually required: Will the iPhone app be rejected for only supporting one orientation?

Thanks in advance

A: 

I have no experience with Apple development whatsoever, but my expectations are they will enforce it because of user expectation. Users most likely expect the app to be usable in all orientations.

Ikke
A: 

No. It's not a requirement.

However, it is so simple to implement in most cases that if your application does not absolutely requires a particular orientation to work(i.e. two hands touches based interaction), it would be sad to not implement it.

VdesmedT
So, should multiple orientations only be supported on the iPad? And if so, considering the app is targeted for the iphone (but will run still run iphone-size on ipad), it would seem a bit odd. Supporting multiple orientations on the iPad means possibly having to have a completely different UI for it. which I was hoping to avoid.
Felixs
+1  A: 

Not necessarily. I have seen an iPad only app which only supports portrait and portrait upside down orientations which has been accepted into the App store. There are also several iPad piano apps in the App store which only display the keyboard the long way (landscape).

You may to support at least two orientations: foo and foo upside down.

hotpaw2
Yes, I can see why certain apps (such as a piano app) might only support one orientation - They've got a good reason; however, mine doesn't...I think I'll add support for both orientations.
Felixs
+1  A: 

The "flixster" app in the appstore only supports landscape and landscape-upside down views, so clearly (along with hotpaw2's answer) at least two people have got away without supporting all the orientations.

Much like anything else to do with app store reviews, I suspect you may or may not get away with it, depending on how the reviewer feels. The documentation says:

"With few exceptions, applications should support all interface orientations on iPad devices."

which would tend to suggest there's a risk (albeit perhaps a small one) that your app will get rejected.

JosephH
Judging by that quote, it looks more like there'll be a pretty large risk of it being rejected. Although now I face the issue of should these multiple orientations only be supported on the iPad? And if so, considering the app is targeted for the iphone (but will run still run iphone-size on ipad), it would seem a bit odd.
Felixs
I keep some of my views only viewable in one rotation on the iphone - with the iphone in landscape view, the usable screen space is so small with the keyboard open that it can be very difficult to layout a form, for example. It depends on the type of app you're doing.
JosephH
+2  A: 

This used to be the case when the iPad was first released a long with the first release of the HIG. This is no longer the case now. They even changed the wording in the HIG.

The key is that whatever orientation you do support, make sure you support both. Meaning, if you do Portrait, then do Portrait upside down too. If you do Landscape Left, then make sure you do Landscape Right.

bstahlhood