tags:

views:

174

answers:

1

If i were to calculate the iPad's amount of RAM based on just the one fact that my iPad App got rejected due to memory warnings twice, and me fixing it, would this violate the developer NDA?

Obviously i know how much memory my App uses, how much the iPhone OS is likely to use and estimate the amount reserved for video memory, then i can deduct from that that the iPad has xxx MB of memory. I just wonder if i can say that number publicly without violating any NDA?

+2  A: 

No. Read the NDA. Your not supposed to reveal any tech specs derived from your access to unreleased products.

Just as a matter of courtesy, you shouldn't do so anyway because you can easily provide people with wrong information. There is no guarantee that the products released to developers will be the products that ship to customers. When I was at Apple, I saw major product changes up to 48 hours before ship. One time, an entire line of unannounced products was killed 24 hours before shipping.

Keep your mouth shut. You may not know what you think you know and you won't be doing yourself or anyone else any favors.

2010-4-16 Edit: For anyone reading this in the future, my answer about the NDA was correct. The rest of the answer is just advice based on 20+ years experience in the industry. The down checks are from people who don't like the advice not from people who disagree with answer about the NDA.

If your serious about the software business, you have to be serious about contracts, yes even contracts signed by checking a checkbox in an installer and yes, even contracts signed with giant faceless corporations.

If you don't want people to be cavalier with your contracts and your intellectual property you have to have the discipline to respect the contracts and intellectual property of others.

Of course, that's just my opinion. You're free to lie, break contracts and tramp over other people's property. Just write me in a couple of decades and tell me how that all turned out for you.

TechZen
true exemplification of an ipuppet, "keep your mouth shut", way to win developers with that attitude
mxmissile
That's the point: i don't have access to the unreleased product (the iPad) and i wouldn't talk about the beta iPhone SDK either. The fact that my app got rejected with memory warnings has nothing to do with the iPad specifically. If only i could find where that damn NDA is hiding - it's nowhere to be found once you've agreed to it.
GamingHorror
@mxmissile -- Ever seen a company make big plans based on unreleased products only to find out its vaporware? Ever seen some starving college student buy something based on rumors only find out it didn't fit their needs? I have and neither one is pretty. It serves no good for anyone to disseminate possibly inaccurate information. It is dishonest to do so after you have acquired the information after agreeing not do talk about it. Having been on both sides of this issue I have learned the hard way not to speculate.
TechZen
I would also point out that companies have been sued because final products did not match the rumors. The juries held the companies liable for not sufficiently discouraging the rumors thereby leading people to make purchases on false information. IRRC, that happened to the publishers of Foxbase back in the early 90s. Companies don't spend all that money on lawyers and get grief from people like you just for the hell of it.
TechZen
@GamingHorror -- Log into the Developers portal and search on non-disclosure agreement. It comes up. It is also available in the installer where you can print it off.
TechZen
Thanks, found it. The issue here is whether it's really "information disclosed by Apple to you" or if this information (speculation really) is something i've come up with on my own, in that case it is not covered by the NDA. I think the latter is the case here. But i won't make it public until the iPad is out just to be on the safe side. I worry about myself here, to think that someone would make an uninformed purchase (or not) based on the amount of RAM of the device is ridiculous. If anyone wants to know, send me an email.
GamingHorror
So now that the iPad has been released it should be OK to talk about this, right?
progrmr
Yes. Did your speculation turn out to be correct?
TechZen
GamingHorror
@GamingHorror -- Thanks, I appreciate that.
TechZen