Game Center API + In-App Purchases API = Two different user accounts for a single app?

Question

Hello. If I have an app that supports Game Center and I'd like to provide Achievements for completing a puzzle pack that's sold as an in-app purchase, how do I sync the iTunes account that's being charged for the in-app purchase with the Game Center user account that's doing the buying? As I understand it, they're two separate user accounts that are accessed in two different locations (The Game Center account is accessed in the Game Center app and the iTunes account is accessed in the Settings app).

How do I avoid this from happening...

1. Game Center Player1 logs in, runs my app and purchases a puzzle pack
2. Game Center Player1 logs out, Game Center Player2 logs in, runs my app and plays to completion the puzzle pack that Player1 purchased and Player2 is awarded the Achievement.
3. Game Center Player2 logs out, Game Center Player1 logs in and finds the puzzle pack he/she purchased as already completed, so Player1 is unable to gain that same achievement.

Am I misunderstanding something with how these user accounts work? If not, is there a way to sync a Game Center account with an iTunes account as players log in and out of my game? Is there any kind of a work around for this problem? This seems like it would be a fairly common issue with any multiplayer games that sell content.

Thanks so much!

Answer 1

That is a good question. :) As far as achievements go, I guess you could store them on the device with the playerId from the logged in GKPlayer, and once an achievement has been finished for a logged in player, you synch with Game Center.

As far as synching iTunes and Game Center accounts I really don't know. Usually you store some information on whether a purchase has been made (i.e. a feature available) on the device. Would it be logical that using that feature (or being allowed to use it) should be device dependent, not GC user dependent? But then what happens if someone uses their account to just download your content again and again to their friends' devices?

Hmm... I hope some other people will share their thoughts on this. But I found that Game Center questions receive very low views and answers :(

Answer 2

I am trying to come up with the solution to resolve this issue as well. If using the server product delivery mode, the problem could be largely resolved. The application sends the purchased items to server;sever deliver the item to application after checking credentials. There are some corner cases I still don't know how to resolve, basically to handle the case when the whole flow is interrupted, which depeneds on the implementation of IAP. Still not 100% sure yet.

Answer 3

So here's how I'm going to do this, it's actually a fairly straightforward approach. I'm going to locally track users progress in the purchased puzzle packs using core data, since it's quick to get up and running. Each time a new GC user logs in, I'll create a new user object and track their progress in the puzzle packs and report the achievements in GC when needed. When that GC user logs in later, I'll just adjust the state of the puzzle packs to match their current progress defined in core data. This way, any iTunes account can purchase the puzzle packs and they'll inherently be available to anyone using the device. Whenever any GC users log into GC and play my app, they'll all have access to the same purchased puzzle packs, but their progress and achievements will be maintained independently of other GC users.

If GC isn't installed on the device, I can disable all GC features and just init the app as tho there's only one default player.

Should be simple to do.